Showing posts with label plant adaptation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label plant adaptation. Show all posts

Oct 1, 2009

Gymnosperms and Angiosperms

Seed plants come in two great groups, and the difference between them is easier to see than it sounds. Crack open a peach and the seed sits inside the flesh. Pick a seed off a pine cone and nothing wraps it at all.

Angiosperms are the flowering plants, and gymnosperms are the cone bearers and their relatives. Both make seeds, and both use pollen. This guide sets them side by side, feature by feature.

The Ovary Makes the Difference

Seeds Inside, Seeds in the Open

In an angiosperm, the ovules sit inside an ovary, which is part of a carpel. After fertilization the ovule becomes a seed, and the ovary usually becomes the fruit around it.

In a gymnosperm, the ovules are not enclosed in an ovary. They sit on the surface of cone scales or on a stalk. The name says as much: gymnosperm means "naked seed".

Careful with that phrase. Not every gymnosperm ovule is completely bare. In the gnetophytes the ovule can be partly enclosed by surrounding tissue. That is still not the same as an ovary and a fruit.

What Counts as a Fruit

In botany a fruit is a mature ovary, usually with its seeds still inside and sometimes with other flower parts attached. The wall of that mature ovary is called the pericarp.

That definition reaches further than the produce aisle. A tomato, a cucumber and a bean pod are all fruits. The wall can be dry and hard instead of soft and sweet. A strawberry is a fruit too, though part of its flesh comes from tissue below the flower rather than from the ovary alone.

A papaya cut in half, showing the seeds held inside the fruit
A papaya split open. The seeds sit inside the fruit, which grew from the ovary of the flower. That is the angiosperm way. Image: Marek Slusarczyk, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Flowers, Cones and How Pollen Travels

Flowers Belong to Angiosperms

Angiosperms have flowers. In a typical flower the sepals protect the bud and the petals often attract visitors. A stamen has a filament topped by an anther, where pollen forms.

The female side is the carpel. It carries a pollen-receiving stigma, a style, and the ovary at the base. A flower can hold one carpel or many, and not every flower has all of these parts.

Gymnosperms have no flowers at all. Their reproductive structures are cones or cone-like shoots: pollen cones that release pollen, and seed cones that hold the ovules.

Labelled diagram of the parts of a flower
The main parts of a flower, the structure that sets angiosperms apart. Image: Pearson Scott Foresman, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Not Every Gymnosperm Counts on Wind

Wind pollinates most conifers, and it also pollinates grasses, which are angiosperms. Animal pollination is far more common among angiosperms, especially by insects.

Gymnosperms are not limited to wind either. Insects pollinate many cycads and some gnetophytes. A few aquatic angiosperms go further still: Vallisneria pollinates at the water surface, and the seagrass Zostera pollinates underwater.

A young female seed cone of Norway spruce
A young female cone of Norway spruce. Ovules form on its scales, with no ovary wrapped around them. Image: Ivar Leidus, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Double Fertilization and the Food in a Seed

Two Fusions in One Visit

Angiosperms do something unusual. Two sperm cells take part. One fertilizes the egg and forms the zygote, which becomes the embryo. The other fuses with two polar nuclei in the central cell, and that fusion usually produces endosperm, the food store.

This event is called double fertilization, and the endosperm-forming version is a hallmark of flowering plants.

One qualification keeps the claim honest. Some gnetophytes have a double-fertilization-like event of their own. It is not the same process, and it does not make endosperm. So the angiosperm version is best described as characteristic of the group, not unique to all plants.

Where the Food Sits

Food storage differs between the two groups. A gymnosperm seed is usually packed with haploid tissue from the female gametophyte. An angiosperm seed usually holds endosperm instead, or stores its food in the cotyledons, or in both.

Cotyledon number is one way angiosperms get sorted. Monocots such as grasses and lilies have one cotyledon. Eudicots such as oaks and beans have two.

The older word "dicot" is worth retiring. It lumped together plants that do not share a single ancestor, so it is not a valid modern group. Eudicots is the name for the large branch, and a few early-diverging angiosperms with two cotyledons sit outside it.

Wood, Leaves and Where Each Group Lives

Tracheids, Vessels and Growth

Wood in most gymnosperms carries water through tracheids, long cells that also help support the trunk. Angiosperm wood usually adds vessel elements, wider cells that join into continuous pipes.

Gnetophytes break the pattern again, because they have vessels too. The lumber trade calls conifer timber softwood and flowering-tree timber hardwood. Those labels describe the source group, not how hard the board feels.

Almost all gymnosperms are woody. Angiosperms cover a wider range, from oaks to dandelions. Most monocots do not grow true wood, because they lack the usual cambium, though bamboo manages tough woody stems by other means.

Leaves and Living Places

Conifers often carry needles or small scales, which limit water loss. That is a common habit rather than a gymnosperm rule. Ginkgo has fan-shaped leaves, cycads have large compound leaves, and some gnetophytes have broad leaves.

Angiosperm leaves vary just as widely, from broad tropical blades to the narrow straps of grass. Where the two groups live differs too. Gymnosperms dominate boreal forests and many cold, dry or high mountain sites. Angiosperms dominate most other habitats, including tropical forests and grasslands.

Diversity is lopsided in the same direction. Roughly 1,100 to 1,200 gymnosperm species are alive, against a rough estimate of 330,000 to 350,000 angiosperms. One Kew estimate counted about 369,400 flowering plants among some 390,900 known vascular plants, close to 94 percent. Treat those counts as estimates, since checklists keep changing.

Spruce cones torn apart by a squirrel, with the seeds exposed
A squirrel left these spruce cones stripped, and the seeds lie in the open. No fruit holds them, which is exactly what "naked seed" means. Image: W.carter, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
FeatureGymnospermsAngiosperms
Seed enclosureOvules and seeds in the open, on scales or stalksOvules inside an ovary, which becomes the fruit
Reproductive structureCones or cone-like shoots, never flowersFlowers, often with sepals, petals, stamens and carpels
FertilizationNo endosperm-forming double fertilizationDouble fertilization forms a zygote and usually endosperm
PollinationMostly wind in conifers; insects in many cycadsAnimals common; wind pollinates grasses and many trees
Seed food tissueUsually haploid female gametophyte tissueEndosperm, cotyledons, or both
WoodMostly tracheids; vessels only in gnetophytesUsually vessel elements as well as tracheids
LeavesOften needles or scales, but also fan and compoundBroad leaves, grass blades and everything between
Living speciesAbout 1,100 to 1,200Roughly 330,000 to 350,000

How the Two Groups Are Related

Angiosperms Are One Branch, Gymnosperms Are Messier

Angiosperms form a single clade, meaning one ancestor and all of its descendants. Living gymnosperms are supported as a group as well, but the arrangement inside it is more tangled than old diagrams suggest.

In a leading current hypothesis the gnetophytes sit among the conifer lineages, which would make the conifers alone an incomplete group. That is a detail for later study, so the safest summary at this level is simple: both groups are seed plants.

When Each Group Appeared

Gymnosperm origins are placed around the mid-Devonian, roughly 385 million years ago, based on current reviews. Angiosperm origins are far less certain.

Molecular work hints at an early history that may reach back toward the Jurassic. Even so, the clearest fossils and the great burst of diversification are Cretaceous. So say that angiosperms diversified greatly through the Cretaceous and rose to dominance over that span, not on one fixed date.

Key Terms in Plain English

TermWhat it means here
AngiospermA flowering plant; its seeds develop inside a fruit.
GymnospermA seed plant whose seeds are not enclosed in a fruit.
OvaryThe flower part that holds the ovules and becomes the fruit.
OvuleThe structure that becomes a seed after fertilization.
FruitA mature ovary, usually with its seeds and sometimes other tissue.
PericarpThe wall of a mature ovary, which is the fruit wall.
CarpelThe female flower part: stigma, style and ovary.
StamenThe male flower part: filament plus anther.
AntherThe part of the stamen where pollen forms.
StigmaThe surface that receives pollen grains.
StyleThe stalk that connects stigma to ovary.
Double fertilizationTwo fusions in angiosperms: egg and polar nuclei.
EndospermThe food tissue of many angiosperm seeds, usually triploid.
CotyledonA seed leaf that stores or absorbs food.
MonocotAn angiosperm with one cotyledon, such as a grass.
EudicotAn angiosperm with two cotyledons, such as an oak.
Vessel elementA wide water-carrying cell typical of angiosperm wood.

Key Takeaways

  • The core difference is the ovary: angiosperm seeds form inside one.
  • Gymnosperm seeds sit in the open, often on the scales of a cone.
  • A fruit is a mature ovary, so tomatoes and bean pods count as fruit.
  • Angiosperms have flowers; gymnosperms have cones and no flowers.
  • Double fertilization and endosperm are characteristic of angiosperms.
  • Wind and animals both pollinate; gymnosperms are not wind-only.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do gymnosperms have flowers?

No. Gymnosperms make cones or cone-like shoots instead. Flowers belong to angiosperms.

Is a pine cone a fruit?

No. A fruit develops from an ovary, and a cone has no ovary. A cone is a cluster of scales that carry the seeds in the open.

Are gymnosperms all evergreen with needles?

No. Larches are deciduous conifers, Ginkgo loses its fan-shaped leaves each autumn, and cycads carry large compound leaves.

Did angiosperms simply replace gymnosperms?

Not really. Angiosperms became dominant in many habitats, but gymnosperms still form vast boreal forests and do well in cold, dry and high places.

Key references
• OpenStax Biology 2e: Angiosperms
• OpenStax Biology 2e: Gymnosperms
• OpenStax Biology 2e: Reproductive development and structure
• University of Minnesota: Fruit morphology
• Yang et al. (2024): Living gymnosperms review
• Kew: State of the World's Plants (vascular plant counts)

Images: Wikimedia Commons, with the author and license named in each caption. This article is general science education.

Advantages of Seed Habit in Spermatophytes (Seed Plants)

Seeds are the reason flowering plants and conifers cover so much of the land. A seed is a young plant packed with its own food and wrapped in a coat. That package can be carried, buried, and left to wait.

Plants that reproduce with spores have no such package. Their offspring leave as single cells and must land somewhere damp enough to survive. This guide explains what the seed habit is and why it worked so well, and it is honest about the costs of the same strategy.

What the Seed Habit Actually Is

A Seed Is Not a Bigger Spore

A spore is one cell. A seed is a multicellular structure that holds an embryo, a store of food, and a protective seed coat. A spore has to build everything after it lands. A seed arrives already built.

A seed develops from an ovule that has been fertilized. An ovule is not a spore either. It is a structure made of parent tissue, holding the female parts inside.

Where the Megaspore Stays

The seed habit is a package of traits, not one feature. Seed plants are heterosporous, meaning they make two sizes of spore. The larger one, the megaspore, is not released.

Instead the megaspore stays inside the parent plant and grows into the female gametophyte there. A layer of parent tissue, the integument, wraps around it. Pollen arrives before the seed is shed. All of that happens before the offspring ever leaves home.

The layers have different origins. The seed coat comes from the parent, so it is diploid. The embryo is diploid too, because it forms from an egg and a sperm. The stored food is different: in gymnosperms it is usually haploid tissue from the female gametophyte, while in flowering plants it is usually endosperm.

The Embryo Travels With Its Own Kit

A Coat That Protects

The seed coat limits water loss and shrugs off small injuries. It is also a first line of defense against fungi and bacteria. Many coats carry a waxy cuticle, and some contain compounds that absorb ultraviolet light.

A coat is protection, not a guarantee. Coats differ a great deal between species, and a cracked or eaten seed is as vulnerable as any other plant tissue.

Food Packed for the First Weeks

Stored food carries the seedling through the days before its first leaves can make sugar. The reserve is mostly starch, protein and oil, held in the cotyledons or in the tissue around the embryo.

That head start matters. A seedling from a big seed can push through soil and leaf litter with energy it never has to earn from sunlight.

Sequence of a navy bean seed germinating into a seedling
A navy bean moving from seed to seedling. The food stored inside carries the plant until its first leaves open. Image: B. Domangue, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Waiting, Then Leaving Home

Dormancy: Waiting for the Right Cue

Some seeds wait instead of sprouting at the first shower. That resting state is called dormancy, and it lets a seed sit out a bad season. Some seeds simply need time. Others need a specific cue before they will break dormancy.

Cold stratification is the cue for dogwood, holly and magnolia seeds. Heat wakes some seeds, and scarification, which weakens a hard coat, is needed by seeds such as redbud and some Zamia. Plenty of seeds need no special treatment at all.

How Long a Seed Can Wait

Viability varies enormously with species and with storage conditions. A review linked to Kew describes seeds of some South African genera that germinated after 218 to 270 years in poor storage.

The same review notes a date palm seed of about 2,000 years that germinated in 2005, and it treats that result as exceptional. Long dormancy is a useful backup, not a normal plan.

Wind and Water

Seeds travel by more routes than spores do. Wings and plumes slow the fall and let wind carry them. Coconuts and other buoyant seeds ride water, sometimes clear across an ocean.

Moving away from the parent is the point. A seed that lands beneath its mother competes with her for light, water and minerals, and it faces the pests and pathogens already gathered on her.

Winged seeds (samaras) of red maple
Winged seeds of red maple. The blade makes each seed spin, which buys it time in the air and distance from the parent tree. Image: Dcrjsr, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Animals as Couriers

Animals move seeds in two main ways. They can carry them on fur or feathers, or they can eat a fleshy fruit and pass the seeds later, often far away. Fleshy fruits are a flowering plant invention.

Ants are a third route. Many seeds grow a small oil-rich parcel called an elaiosome. Ants carry the seed to the nest to eat the parcel, and the seed itself ends up safely buried.

Several seeds each bearing a pale, oil-rich elaiosome
Seeds with elaiosomes. The pale parcel is food for ants, and the burying that follows protects the seed. Image: Hans Stuessi, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Reproduction Without a Film of Water

Pollen Delivers the Sperm

Mosses and ferns need a film of water for fertilization. Their sperm have tails and must swim to an egg. Seed plants broke that link.

A pollen grain is the small male gametophyte, not a sperm cell. It is carried to the ovule by wind or by an animal, and there it grows a pollen tube that delivers sperm cells to the egg.

What That Does Not Mean

Pollen raises a common misunderstanding. Seed plants still need water to grow, and their seedlings die without it. What they escaped was the need for liquid water at the moment of fertilization.

One more detail is worth keeping. In cycads and Ginkgo the sperm still have tails. They swim a short distance inside the ovule after the pollen tube has delivered them.

Pollen grains resting on the surface of a primula stigma
Pollen grains on a primula stigma. From here a tube grows down toward the egg, so no free water is needed for fertilization. Image: Ergriffi, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

From the Devonian to the Forests We Have

Early Seed Plants

The earliest seed-like fossils are old. Runcaria, from about 385 million years ago in the Middle Devonian, is treated as a precursor rather than a finished seed.

By the Late Devonian, roughly 365 million years ago, plants such as Elkinsia and Moresnetia carried seed-like structures. Elkinsia polymorpha is often called the oldest known seed plant. Early seed plants then diversified during the Carboniferous, sharing the landscape with ferns and club mosses rather than replacing them at once.

Why Seed Plants Came to Dominate

Through the Mesozoic, seed plants built most forests, and gymnosperms were the main trees. Flowering plants appeared later and had overtaken them in many habitats by about 100 million years ago.

Today the numbers are lopsided. A 2022 global count found roughly 369,000 described vascular plant species, including about 13,800 ferns and lycophytes and about 355,000 seed plants. That put seed plants at around 96 percent of the total in that dataset.

Seeds were not the only reason. Vascular tissue and woody growth mattered too. The seed simply removed one hard limit on where a plant could reproduce.

What the Seed Habit Costs

A seed is expensive. The parent builds an embryo, a coat and a food store, and that effort yields a single dispersal unit with, usually, one embryo.

Seeds also fail. Dormancy can keep a seed waiting until the parent plant is gone, and stored seeds lose viability over time. Seed banks buy time rather than immortality.

The trade is still a good one. A spore gambles on landing somewhere wet. A seed arrives protected, fed and able to wait, which is why forests are made of seed plants.

Key Terms in Plain English

TermWhat it means here
SpermatophyteA seed plant, including gymnosperms and flowering plants.
SeedAn embryo with stored food, wrapped in a protective coat.
Seed habitThe package of traits that produce and shed seeds.
OvuleThe structure holding the female parts that becomes a seed.
IntegumentThe parent tissue around an ovule that becomes the seed coat.
EmbryoThe young plant inside the seed, formed from egg and sperm.
Seed coatThe protective outer layer of a seed, from the integument.
EndospermStored food in flowering plant seeds, usually triploid.
CotyledonA seed leaf that often holds the stored food.
DormancyA resting state in which a seed will not germinate yet.
StratificationA cold period that breaks dormancy in some seeds.
ScarificationWeakening a hard seed coat so water can enter.
DispersalMovement of seeds away from the parent plant.
ElaiosomeAn oil-rich parcel that attracts ants to a seed.
PollenThe small male gametophyte carried to the ovule.
Pollen tubeThe tube that carries sperm cells to the egg.
HeterosporousMaking two sizes of spore, as seed plants do.

Key Takeaways

  • A seed is an embryo plus stored food inside a protective coat.
  • The seed habit keeps the megaspore on the parent and wraps it in an integument.
  • The coat protects the embryo and the food supply gives the seedling a head start.
  • Dormancy lets a seed wait for the right season instead of sprouting at once.
  • Wings, water, fruit and ants all move seeds away from the parent plant.
  • Pollen ends the need for a water film at fertilization, but plants still need water.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a seed just a large spore?

No. A spore is a single cell. A seed holds a multicellular embryo with stored food and a coat, so it starts life far better supplied.

Do seed plants never need water?

They need water to grow, and seedlings die without it. What pollen removed was the need for liquid water at the moment of fertilization.

Do all seeds germinate as soon as they get wet?

No. Many seeds stay dormant until they get the right cue, such as a cold spell, heat or a damaged coat. Others sprout readily.

Why are most land plants seed plants?

A protected embryo, a built-in food supply and the ability to wait give seeds an edge in dry, cold and disturbed places where spores struggle.

Key references
• OpenStax Biology 2e: Evolution of seed plants
• OpenStax Biology 2e: Gymnosperms
• Milne open botany text: The development of seeds
• UC Museum of Paleontology: Seed plant fossil record
• Porteous et al. (2019): Seed longevity review
• University of Florida IFAS: Seed dormancy and pretreatment

Images: Wikimedia Commons, with the author and license named in each caption. This article is general science education.