Aug 28, 2021

Thermoregulation: How Animals and Plants Hold Their Temperature

A lizard on a hot rock and a shivering seal on an ice floe are both solving the same problem, and they solve it in opposite ways. One borrows heat from the sun. The other spends its own fuel to refuse it. Neither is more advanced than the other, and neither is what a word like cold-blooded really means.

This post explains how temperature is controlled, and why the two words students most often mix up are not the same word.

Two Words That Are Not the Same Word

Most confusion about animal temperature comes from treating homeothermy and endothermy as though one implied the other. They describe different things.

  • Homeothermy is about how STABLE the temperature is. A homeotherm holds a narrow range whatever the weather does.
  • Poikilothermy is the opposite. The internal temperature wanders with the surroundings.
  • Endothermy is about where the HEAT COMES FROM. An endotherm generates it inside, by metabolism.
  • Ectothermy is the opposite. The environment supplies most of it.

Those are two questions, not four kinds of animal. A desert lizard basking in the sun and retreating to shade at noon can hold a body temperature steady within a degree or two across a whole day. That is homeothermy, and it is achieved by behavior alone. It is still an ectotherm, because the heat came from outside.

Diagram contrasting homeothermy with poikilothermy
Stability and heat source are separate questions, so a lizard can be stable without making its own heat — Image: Petter Bøckman, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The everyday words warm-blooded and cold-blooded are worse than the technical ones. A lizard basking in the sun can run hotter than a person standing next to it. What endotherms really have is a much higher resting metabolic rate, and enough mitochondria per cell to burn fat and sugar quickly.

Every Animal Is a Heat Balance

Whatever an animal is, its temperature settles where heat gained equals heat lost. Three things push heat in.

  • Metabolism. Every cell doing work releases heat as a by-product. At rest this is obligatory thermogenesis, and it covers processes you cannot switch off, like active transport and heart muscle.
  • The sun. Direct radiation, and heat conducted from warm rock or air the animal is sitting on.
  • The surroundings. Warm water, a warm burrow, another animal.

And four things push it out: evaporation of water, radiation into cooler air, conduction into a cooler surface, and convection into moving air or water.

Diagram of heat moving in and out of a body
Temperature settles where heat in equals heat out. Everything below is about shifting that balance — Image: J. W. Dietrich, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Behavior is the cheapest thermostat

An ectotherm regulates mostly by moving. A lizard climbs onto a rock in the morning and into shade at midday. An animal in a burrow is insulated from the wind. Standing in one place all day is unusual for a reptile, and for good reason.

Turtles basking on a log in direct sun
This is a reptile raising its body temperature by conduction and radiation — Image: Oxlamb, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Where the Thermostat Sits

In both ectotherms and endotherms, the main control point is the preoptic area of the front of the hypothalamus, a small region near the center of the brain.

Diagram showing the hypothalamus in the brain
The hypothalamus sits below the thalamus and above the pituitary — Image: BruceBlaus, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

In mammals the mechanism is now well understood at the level of single neurons. Cells in the preoptic area send a steady stream of inhibitory signals, using the transmitter GABA, to brainstem regions that control the body’s heating and cooling apparatus.

  • When it is hot, those inhibitory signals strengthen. Heat production is suppressed and skin blood vessels widen, so heat escapes.
  • When it is cold, the inhibition is lifted. Heat production rises and skin vessels constrict, so heat is held in.
  • Fever works the same way, except prostaglandin E2 weakens the inhibition and the set point moves up.

That last point matters. The thermostat is not measuring the outside temperature and reacting. It is defending a set point it carries internally, and a fever is that set point being raised deliberately. You feel hot because you are below your new normal, not because you are too hot.

Diagram of a negative feedback control loop
Sensor, control center, effector, and a return signal. Thermoregulation is this loop run in both directions — Image: explorebiology, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

How an Endotherm Makes Heat

Heat comes from burning fuel, but there is more than one way to burn it, and the difference matters.

Shivering: motion that produces nothing

Shivering is a mechanical tremor in which almost all the energy spent appears as heat. No useful movement comes out of it. That is the point. It is also how a hibernating bat or ground squirrel warms up as it comes out of hibernation, before its own furnace is running again.

Non-shivering: a furnace built to waste energy

Brown fat contains uncoupling protein 1, also called thermogenin. It sits in the inner membrane of the mitochondrion and lets hydrogen ions cross back into the cell without passing through the ATP synthase.

That sounds like a leak, and it is. In a normal cell the energy of those protons is captured as ATP. Here it is released as heat instead. The cell burns fat and oxygen at high rate and produces very little usable energy, because making heat is the entire objective.

Medical scan showing metabolically active brown fat
Brown fat runs its furnace at a temperature that makes it light up on a metabolic scan — Image: Hg6996, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Brown fat is present in almost all placental mammals. The pig is the only known exception. It sits around the neck, collarbone, spine and the major blood vessels, which is exactly where you would want heat delivered.

Countercurrent exchange

Warm arterial blood travelling out to a paw passes close beside cool venous blood coming back. Heat moves from the warm blood into the cool blood, so it returns to the body instead of escaping into the air. A standing animal loses very little heat through its feet.

Diagram of countercurrent heat exchange in a limb
The two flows run in opposite directions, so heat is transferred along the whole length — Image: Cruithne9, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Shape follows the same logic. Warm-blooded animals in cold climates tend to be bigger than their relatives in warm ones. That is Bergmann’s rule, and it works because a large body has a smaller surface area relative to its volume. Short extremities lose less too.

These are patterns across groups, not laws. Every one of them has exceptions, and a rule about a trend is not a rule about any single animal.

What Happens When It Fails

The body has limits, and crossing them has names.

StateMeaningFigures
Normal core temperaturethe defended rangeabout 37 C (98.6 F)
Hyperthermiacore temperature rises above normala serious strain on the body
Lethal heat stresswet bulb temperature the body cannot compensate forabout 30.55 C, found experimentally in 2022
Hypothermiacore temperature falls below normalsets in below 35 C (95 F)

The wet bulb figure is the interesting one. Wet bulb temperature combines air temperature with humidity, because humidity decides how well sweat can evaporate. It is the measure that best predicts whether a person can shed heat at all. The same figure reached for six hours is the threshold for lethal heat stress in an adult.

Hibernation Is About Metabolism, Not Temperature

The word hibernation is usually pictured as deep cold and near-freezing. In animals it is better defined by a drop in metabolic rate, and on that measure a bear is genuinely hibernating. A bear’s body temperature falls far less than a rodent’s, but its metabolic rate plummets by roughly three quarters.

A woodchuck, a ground squirrel, deep in hibernation
Weeks or months of very low metabolic rate, surviving on stored fat — Image: Cephas, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Before sleeping through winter, an animal has to store enough fuel to last. Larger species simply eat a great deal and become fat. Smaller ones cache food instead. Daily torpor and hibernation are better seen as a continuum using similar mechanisms than as separate things. Female black bears hibernate through the birth of their cubs, living on stored fat and losing 15 to 27 percent of their pre-hibernation weight doing it.

Plants Do It Too, and Some Heat Deliberately

A plant cannot move to a warmer place, so it manages temperature differently. Leaves lose water through their stomata, and that evaporation cools the plant. Heat-shock proteins appear during heat stress and stabilise enzymes that would otherwise unfold. In cold, plants adjust the unsaturated fats in their membranes so the cells stay fluid instead of crystallising.

Some plants run a furnace

A small number of plants generate heat on purpose, in a process with the same name as the mammal mechanism: thermogenesis. The eastern skunk cabbage can raise its own temperature several degrees above the surrounding air in early spring. The voodoo lily does the same, and can hold its flowers near 40 C for days.

The voodoo lily in flower
Its spadix heats itself, which volatilises scent and draws in pollinators — Image: Krzysztof Ziarnek, Kenraiz, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

There is a reason this is not just waste. The heat volatilises scent compounds, so the plant can attract pollinators in early spring when almost nothing else is flowering. The giant water lilies of the genus Victoria do it too, and their leaves can hold themselves clear of the water by generating heat that breaks the surface tension.

The giant water lily Victoria amazonica
A plant that makes its own heat and floats on it — Image: Bilby, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The Vocabulary in One Table

TermThe question it answersYes / no
Homeothermyis the temperature stable?a narrow range / it wanders
Endothermywhere does the heat come from?made inside / borrowed outside
Hibernationis the metabolic rate suppressed?by metabolic drop, not by cold alone
Countercurrent exchangehow is heat kept in a limb?returning blood takes the heat back
Thermogenesishow is heat made?shivering, brown fat, or in some plants

Key Takeaways

  • Homeothermy is about stability. Endothermy is about the source of heat. They are two independent questions and neither implies the other.
  • A desert lizard can hold a steady temperature using only behavior, and still be an ectotherm.
  • Body temperature settles where heat gained equals heat lost.
  • The hypothalamus acts as the thermostat. It defends a set point rather than reacting to the outside temperature.
  • A fever is that set point being raised. You feel hot because you are below your new normal.
  • Shivering turns motion into heat. Brown fat turns fuel into heat directly, using uncoupling protein 1.
  • Countercurrent exchange returns heat from the extremities to the body, so little is lost through the feet.
  • Hibernation is defined by metabolic suppression, so a bear qualifies even though its temperature barely falls.
  • Some plants generate heat deliberately to volatilise scent and draw in pollinators early in the season.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a homeotherm the same as an endotherm?

No. Homeothermy describes how steady the temperature is, and endothermy describes where the heat comes from. Many homeotherms are endotherms, but some ectotherms are homeotherms by behavior alone.

Are cold-blooded animals really cold?

No. A lizard in direct sun can have a higher body temperature than a mammal standing nearby. The term describes where the heat comes from, not how warm the animal is. Poikilothermy is the more accurate word for animals whose temperature varies with the surroundings.

Do homeotherms maintain a perfectly constant temperature?

No, a narrow range, not a fixed value. Body temperature moves a little through the day, with activity, sleep and the outside weather. Humans run near 37 C but it is not identical hour to hour.

How does shivering produce heat?

The muscles contract rhythmically without producing movement, so nearly all the energy released appears as heat. It is heat generation that happens to use a mechanical method.

What is brown fat for?

It is a furnace. Uncoupling protein 1 lets protons cross the mitochondrial membrane without making ATP, so fuel is burned and the energy leaves as heat. It sits near the neck, collarbone, spine and major blood vessels, where heat is most useful.

Is hibernation the same as being cold?

No. Hibernation is defined by metabolic suppression, not by body temperature. A bear’s temperature falls only a few degrees while its metabolic rate drops by around three quarters, and it still counts as hibernation.

Do plants feel temperature?

They respond to it precisely, without nerves. Stomata close in drought and heat, membranes change their fats in cold, and heat-shock proteins appear in heat. A few species go further and generate heat deliberately, which is thermogenesis in the botanical sense too.

Sources: Wikipedia articles on thermoregulation, homeothermy, poikilothermy, endotherm, ectotherm, hypothalamus, thermogenesis, hibernation, nest and thermal conduction. Images: Wikimedia Commons, with authors and licenses noted in each caption.

1 comment:

  1. What an outstanding piece of writing! The way you’ve articulated your ideas makes it easy to engage with and learn from. I really appreciate the effort you put into creating such high-quality content. This blog is quickly becoming one of my favorites—keep up the fantastic work!
    Enrgtech
    SMC Thermo Chiller

    ReplyDelete